| | 1. Abraham Bates, b. 03 Sep 1832 [Natural] |
| | 2. Hugh Bates, b. 13 Nov 1833 [Natural] |
| | 3. Rebecca Bates, b. 26 Apr 1835 [Natural] |
| | 4. Simeon Bates, b. 16 Oct 1836 [Natural] |
| + | 5. Harriett Bates, b. 29 Jun 1838 [Natural] |
| | 6. Lewis Bates, b. 10 Jan 1840, Noble Co, OH  , d. 14 May 1886, Noble Co, OH (Age 46 years) [Natural] |
| | 7. Patrick Bates, b. 17 Dec 1841 [Natural] |
| | 8. Roseline Bates, b. 14 Jul 1843 [Natural] |
| | 9. Herman Bates, b. 10 Apr 1845 [Natural] |
| | 10. Louanna Bates [Natural] |
| | 11. Susanna Bates, b. 29 Nov 1849 [Natural] |
| | 12. Bethel Bates, b. 15 Jan 1852 [Natural] |
| | 13. Levi Bates, b. 27 Sep 1853 [Natural] |
